Searches for what is a dick rating come from fans who saw it on a menu and from creators who were asked for one. The answer is the same for both, and it is less strange than it sounds: it is a custom, the simplest one there is.
What a dick rating is.
A fan pays, sends a photo of himself, and receives a personal review from the creator. The review usually has a score out of ten, a few specific comments, and a closing line in the creator's voice. It can be written, spoken or filmed. Dick rating and cock rating mean the same thing, and a fan asking what are dick rates is asking about the same service.
It is a custom in the platform's sense: content made for one fan, on request, for a stated price. That is what separates it from the unsolicited photos creators receive every day. A rating is requested, priced and paid for before anything is sent.
Why it sells.
The fan is not buying information. He is buying a moment of the creator's direct attention, about him, in the creator's voice. Nothing else on a menu is as personal for as little work, which is why ratings convert new subscribers into buyers and why they lead to larger customs. They are also faceless friendly and need no shoot, so they suit a page at any stage. The messages guide explains why most of a page's income is made in the inbox, and this is the inbox's entry product.
Good dick ratings share a vibe: playful, specific and positive unless the fan asked otherwise. Most fans ordering ratings want feedback that makes them feel seen, and a rating that is fun to read gets a reply, a tip and a second order. Size is the thing fans are most anxious about and the thing a skilled creator spends the least time on; shape, grooming, the photo itself and the confidence behind it give more to say and leave the fan feeling better. Quick, warm interactions like this are what make ratings the start of a regular, and why some creators offer one free rating to new subscribers as a welcome and charge for every rating after it.
The formats.
| Format | What the fan gets | Work for the creator | Place on the menu |
|---|---|---|---|
| Text rating | A written review with a score | A few minutes of typing | The cheapest item |
| Voice note rating | The review spoken in the creator's voice | One take, no camera | The middle item |
| Video rating | The creator on camera reacting and rating | Setup, one take, upload | The premium item |
| Themed rating | The same, in a tone the fan asks for: kind, honest, teasing or harsh | Depends on the format | An add on, priced above the plain version |
Tone is chosen by the fan, not assumed. Some want praise, some want an honest opinion, and some ask for a humiliating review as a kink of its own. A harsh rating is only ever delivered when it was the thing ordered.
Which ratings to offer depends on the page. A playful persona sells fun, positive ratings with a joke in them; a stricter persona sells honest feedback and harsh ratings by request. Offering two or three kinds of ratings, each with a name and a price, works better than one, because fans making a first purchase like to choose. Whatever the tone, the fan should feel the rating was about him: mention something only his photo shows, not only size, and the feedback reads as real. Creators who get repeat orders for ratings are the ones whose ratings are worth showing off.
How to do a dick rating.
- 1
Put it on the menu
List each format with its price and delivery time in the tip menu and the welcome message, so the fan knows the terms before asking.
- 2
Take payment first
The fan tips the menu price with a note saying which rating he wants, or unlocks a paid message. No payment, no rating: photos sent without one go unanswered.
- 3
Ask two questions
Which tone he wants, and whether there is anything he wants mentioned. This takes a minute and is what makes the result feel made for him.
- 4
Write or record it to a structure
Use the same structure every time, below, and fill it with specifics from the photo. A generic rating reads as one.
- 5
Deliver on time, then offer the next step
Send it inside the stated window and mention the next format up. A text rating that landed well is the easiest sale of a voice or video one.
What makes ratings sell.
- Match the vibe of the page. Ratings should sound like everything else the persona says. A playful page gives playful ratings; a strict page gives strict ones. Fans notice when the vibe changes.
- Give feedback, not a number. The score is one line. The feedback around it is what the fan reads twice, so make it specific and, unless he asked otherwise, positive.
- Do not make it about size. Size is one detail among several. Ratings that lead with it feel like a verdict; ratings that cover shape, grooming and the photo feel like attention.
- Keep it quick. A quick turnaround matters more than length. Ratings delivered while the fan is still online lead to more interactions and more sales than long ones delivered tomorrow.
- Make it fun to receive. Ratings with a sense of fun get shared in the chat, answered and tipped. Making the fan feel good about asking is what brings him back.
- Use free ratings sparingly. A free rating as a welcome offer can start interactions with new subscribers. Free ratings as a habit teach fans that ratings have no price.
- Have a style. A scoring style of your own, named categories, a sign off, makes your ratings recognizable and worth more than generic ones.
An example structure.
A dick rating example does not need to be explicit to be useful, because what makes a rating good is its structure. Every strong one has the same five parts.
| Part | What it does | What it sounds like |
|---|---|---|
| Opening | Uses his name and sets the tone he chose | A greeting that shows this was written for him, not pasted |
| First impression | One honest reaction to the photo as a whole | What you noticed first, including lighting and effort |
| Three criteria | A short comment and a score on each of three named points | For example proportions, grooming and presentation, each out of ten |
| Overall score | The number he paid for | A score out of ten with one sentence of reasoning |
| Closing | Ends in your persona's voice and opens the next sale | One line in character, and what he could order next |
Keep the criteria fixed and the comments specific. A creator who rates on the same three points every time can write one in a few minutes, and the fan can tell it was his photo that was looked at.
The approach that keeps fans engaging is to treat the rating as the start of a conversation. A real reaction to his photo, a teasing question at the end, a comment on the lighting or the effort he put into making it: each gives him something to answer. A rating that ends the exchange earns once. One that keeps it going, with a positive, engaging tone and a vibe that matches the page, is how a creator with a recognizable style turns a first purchase into a regular. Start every rating with his name and end it with a reason to reply.
Types of rating, with examples.
Clients ask for a dick rating in a few recognizable types, and a creator who names them on the menu saves both sides a conversation. The type decides the tone, not the score: an honest rating can still be kind, and a humiliation rating is only ever delivered to a client who asked for exactly that. The examples below show the shape of each, in the words an adult creator would actually use, without describing anyone's penis in detail; the detail comes from the client's own photo.
| Type | What the client wants | Example of the tone | Format that suits it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Honest rating | A real opinion, good and bad | "Clear photo, good light, nice shape. I'd score it a 7 and here is why." | Text or audio |
| Praise rating | Confidence; to hear what works | "You were nervous to send this and you didn't need to be." | Audio or video |
| Humiliation rating | Teasing or mockery as a kink, by request only | Playful put downs agreed in advance, never about anything he did not ask to be teased for | Text or audio |
| Comparison rating | Where he stands on your scale | "Against everything I've rated this month, this sits near the top for grooming." | Text |
| Video reaction | To see your first reaction | An unscripted first look, then the score | Video |
Humiliation ratings, often called small penis humiliation, are a kink of their own and sit close to the line between a scene and harm. Ask what the client wants teased and what is off limits, and refuse anything that touches real insecurities he did not offer. Many men who order one want the same thing as men who order praise: attention, from a person, about them.
- Ask for a clear photo. Good light, in focus, the client's own body. A rating of a blurry photo helps nobody.
- Write the menu by type. Honest, praise, humiliation, video reaction, each with a price and a format.
- Consider audio first. An audio rating is personal, quick to make and needs no camera; many creators find it the format clients reorder.
- Keep requests on the platform. Photos, payment and the rating all through the inbox, so there is a record if a client disputes it.
- Adults only, and only his own photo. If a photo looks like anyone else's or anyone under 18, do not rate it; report it.
How to price it.
There is no standard price and no sourced figure for what ratings earn, so none is quoted here. The logic is the same as for any menu item. Price by the creator's time and by how personal the format is: text lowest, voice above it, video highest, themed versions above their plain equivalents. Set the text rating low enough to be an easy first purchase, because its job is to turn a subscriber into a buyer. Then read the numbers after a month: if nearly everyone who asks buys, the price is too low. The tip menu guide covers how a menu is laid out and the PPV guide covers paid messages.
Style is the last pricing lever. A creator whose ratings have a recognizable style, a running joke, a scoring system with its own names, a signature sign off, can charge more for ratings than one whose ratings read like a form, because fans are buying the persona as much as the score.
Many fans order a dick rating for confidence as much as for fun. They want the experience of being looked at by someone they find attractive and told, in a real voice, what works. A dick rating that is honest and kind does that well; a fan who gets that has a reason to return, because the experience was good and the confidence was real. The experience of the fan, not the score, is the product.
Is it worth the money?
For a creator, dick ratings are among the cheapest services to make on any adult platform: no shoot, no set, a few minutes per request. That is why so many creators offer them, and also why the money is in volume and in what comes after. A rating that makes a client feel seen often leads to a voice note, a custom, or a subscription renewal, so the first rating is priced to be easy to buy and the follow up is where a page earns. Different platforms handle ratings differently: on OnlyFans they are sold through tips and paid messages, and the platform takes its 20 percent like any other sale, per its terms.
For a client, the value is the person behind the rating. A rating from a creator he follows, in her voice, about his photo, is worth more to him than any number. Creators who understand that charge by format and by how personal the rating is, and they do not compete on being the cheapest rater on the site.
The rules.
- Adults only, and only his own photo. Fans on the platform are required by the terms to be 18 or older. If a photo appears to show someone under 18, or someone other than the sender, do not rate it; report it through the platform.
- On the platform only. A rating paid for through a payment app has no record and no protection for either side.
- A person writes it. The terms hold the creator responsible for the account, and the platform's help center says creators cannot use AI chatbots to write chats or messages. A rating produced by a bot is both a breach and a worse product.
- Nothing the acceptable use policy forbids. The policy applies to messages as it does to posts. The rules guide covers the layers.
- Your limits are part of the menu. What tones you offer and what you do not is yours to state, in advance.
The service and its formats are described in general terms; this page did not survey menus or prices. The chatbot rule is from the platform's help center; the rules on fans' age and the creator's responsibility for the account are from the OnlyFans Terms of Service. No prices or earnings are quoted because none has a named source.
Sources.
- OnlyFans Terms of Service: the 20 percent fee, creator responsibility, chargebacksonlyfans.com/terms
- OnlyFans Acceptable Use Policy: the list of prohibited content and conductonlyfans.com
- OnlyFans Blog, Ultimate Guide to OnlyFans Features: tips and paid messagesblog.onlyfans.com
- OnlyFans Help Center, "Can I use AI chatbots or AI-generated chat content in chats or direct messages?": No (For Creators, updated November 25, 2025; read through a published copy, as the help center blocks automated reading)onlyfans.com/help